The Sibley Group at Keller Williams Realty 455-0100

Your Home For New Orleans Real Estate

  • Home
  • Sellers
    • Make a Good First Impression
    • What’s My Home Worth?
    • Determining The Value of Your Home
    • Foreclosure & Short Sales
      • What is a “Short Sale”?
      • Short Sale Process
    • Real Estate Glossary
  • Buyers
    • Find Homes For Sale
    • Get Pre-Approved
    • Making an Offer
    • Mortgage Resource Center
      • FHA Loans
      • RD Financing – Rural Development Loans
      • VA Loans
      • Construction & Renovation Loans
    • Real Estate Glossary
  • Communities
    • Northshore
      • Slidell
      • Mandeville
      • Covington
    • Southshore
      • Uptown
      • Garden District
      • Carrollton / University
      • Broadmoor
      • Lakeview
      • Mid City
      • Warehouse District and CBD
      • French Quarter
      • Marigny and Bywater
      • Metairie
  • Resources
    • Local Area Schools
    • Moving Center
    • Preferred Vendors
    • Hurricane Preparedness
    • Blog
  • Listings
    • View Our Listings
    • Search All Listings
  • About Us
    • The Sibley Group
      • Our Team
      • Reviews & Testimonials
    • Keller Williams Realty
    • Careers
    • Choosing a REALTOR
    • Client Services
  • Contact Us
  • Property SearchSearch Homes By Map
  • Listings By EmailListings Updates Sent To Your Inbox
  • Home ValuationWhat Is Your Home Worth?
  • My AccountLogin To Save Listings And Searches
You are here: Home / Blog / If Your House’s Price Is Not Compelling, It’s Not Selling

If Your House’s Price Is Not Compelling, It’s Not Selling

January 22, 2025 by John Sibley

If Your House’s Price Is Not Compelling, It’s Not Selling Simplifying The Market

There’s one big mistake you need to avoid when you sell your house this year: setting your price too high. It might seem like overpricing gives you room to negotiate or could really boost your profit, but the reality is, it usually backfires.

In fact, Realtor.com says almost 20% of sellers — that’s one in five — have to reduce their price to get their house sold. And you don’t want to be one of them. Here’s why starting too high can lead to trouble, and how to avoid it.

Overpricing Pushes Buyers Away

With mortgage rates and home prices where they are right now, buyers are already stretching their budgets to make a move. So, when they see a house that’s priced too high, they’re not thinking, “I can negotiate.” They’re more likely to think, “next” and skip over your house entirely. An article from the National Association of Realtors (NAR) explains:

“Some sellers are pricing their homes higher than ever just because they can, but this may drive away serious buyers . . .”

And if they skip over your listing, you’ll miss out on the chance to get them through the door. That’s the last thing you want because fewer showings mean fewer chances to receive an offer.

The Longer Your House Sits, the More Skeptical Buyers Will Get

Here’s the other issue. An overpriced house tends to sit on the market longer. And the longer a house lingers, the more buyers start to wonder what’s wrong with it. Is there a problem with the house itself? Are you difficult to work with? Even if the only issue is the price, that extra time creates doubt. As U.S. News says:

“. . . setting an unrealistically high price with the idea that you can come down later doesn’t work in real estate . . . A home that’s overpriced in the beginning tends to stay on the market longer, even after the price is cut, because buyers think there must be something wrong with it.”

At that point, you’ll have no choice but to lower your price to drum up interest. But that price reduction comes with its own downside: buyers may see it as another red flag, that there’s an issue with the house.

The Key To Finding the Right Price for Your House

So, what’s the secret to avoiding all these headaches? It’s simple. Work with a local real estate agent who knows the market inside and out, and who’s going to be honest with you about how you should price your house.

You don’t want to partner with someone who just agrees to whatever number you throw out there. That’s not an expert who’s going to get you the best results.

You want an agent who recommends a price based on their expertise. The right agent will use real-time data from your local market to help you land on a price that makes sense — one that grabs attention, attracts buyers, and still helps you walk away with a great return. Someone who has been there and done that – and done it well. That’s the agent you want to work with.

Bottom Line

Remember, if the price isn’t compelling, it’s not selling. Instead of shooting too high and scaring off buyers, work with a local agent who knows how to price it right.

Connect with an agent to make sure your house hits the market with the right price, gets noticed, and gets sold.

Receive A Free Guide To Buying or Selling Your Home

The process of buying or selling a home can be overwhelming at times. It’s difficult to know when is the best time to buy, or how to get the most money for your house when selling. You don't need to go through the process alone.

Our free eGuides will answer many of your questions and likely bring up a few things you didn’t even know you should consider when buying or selling a home.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Filed Under: Blog, For Sellers, Home Prices, Selling Tips

Homes By Price Range

Homes Under $200,000

Homes $200,000 – $300,000

Homes $300,000 – $400,000

Homes $400,000 – $500,000

Homes $500,000 – $600,000

Homes $600,000 – $750,000

Homes $750,000 – $1,000,000

Homes Over $1,000,000

Homes by School District

  • Your Contact Information

WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING

Listened, were easy to reach, and delivered on what they promised.

Default Avatar75
Ashley, New Orleans, LA
 

I worked with Gana, OMG what a GEM !!! Gana made this entire experience pleasurable. Her knowledge, patience and go-getter attitude won me over 100%.

Avatar
Monique C Thomas
 

I worked with Gana to purchase my first home in March 2018. Gana definitely helped me out during this process. She stayed in contact with me and was very good with her timeliness on updates. She was there throughout the whole process and was very knowledgeable when i had any questions. Gana made sure I understood any documents that I had to sign before I completed the action. I would definitely recommend her!

Default Avatar75
Lamar, Slidell, LA
 

There are not enough words that can describe Lana. She absolutely made our experience of finding a home as easy and stress free it could be. Her communication skills are top notch. She answered all of our questions, which were many, in a very timely manner. She went out of her way to set up appointments and send us links for everything that we needed to get done. She did everything in a spirit of excellence. There is no other person I would want or recommend as an agent than, Lana Leonard(...)

Default Avatar75
Shawn & Suzanne, Lacombe, LA
 

I bought my first home!!! Jordan provided exceptional service. At first, I was looking to rent, but she showed me I could get more of what I needed for less if I considered purchasing a home. It is an investment in my future and I am so glad she helped me feel confident in my ability to buy a home. The Sibley Group is a wonderful team that is there for your needs and supports you every step of the way. I highly recommend them, especially Jordan. She was attentive, resourceful, knowledgea(...)

Default Avatar75
Melissa, Covington, LA
 

Mrs. Gana is quite the gem, in fact, the entire Sibley Group were all so helpful and made our first home buying experience a breeze.

We were totally lost when it came to finding a mortgage company and having a realtor with such expertise and experience really put us at ease. She set up connections with several lenders and from there we were put on a path to home ownership!

I would recommend Mrs.Gana a million times again and the Sibley(...)

Default Avatar75
Michelle, Slidell, LA
 

The decision to sell our home and to use the Sibley Realty Group was a year long process. We were concerned about determining the right time to sell and determining a fair and appropriate asking price. We had questions about how to adequately prepare our home for photos and showings. We were concerned about security and showing our home while we were away on vacation. John Sibley addressed all of our questions and concerns. He walked us through the process from listing to closing. He was a(...)

Default Avatar75
Annemarie & Jerry, Slidell, LA
 

We were having troubles trying to figure out the particulars of buying a house and were a little intimidated about approaching a Real Estate agent. Those fears were put to rest after meeting Gana.

She not only guided us through the entire process, but made it a point to go over the contract with verbiage that we understood as first time home buyers- that was important.

The entire experience was smooth, as she laid to rest any fears we(...)

Default Avatar75
Willliam, Slidell, LA
 

Everyone at the Sibley Realty Group was exceptional. From the first phone call to the closing of the home we had the best service. I would recommend Jordan and her team to anyone. Awesome Job Guys! And thanks again.

Default Avatar75
Anonymous, New Orleans, LA
 

Gana made this transaction easy to understand for us as first time home buyers. Gana was very in tune with us when she could tell I didn't understand something. She slowed everything down and made sure I understood before we moved on.

Default Avatar75
Anonymous, Slidell, LA
 

From Our Blog

Housing Market Forecasts for the Second Half of the Year

From rising home prices to mortgage rate swings, the housing market has left a lot of people … [Read More...]

Why Some Homes Sell Faster Than Others

As you think ahead to your own move, you may have noticed some houses sell within days, while others … [Read More...]

About Us

The Sibley Group has a team of Realtors to meet all of your real estate needs throughout the New Orleans Metropolitan area. We have agents that specialize on the Northshore and Southshore, including New Orleans, Slidell, Metairie, Covington, Mandeville, Pearl River, and Lacombe.


Trust a real estate team with a long-standing tradition of service, expertise, and professionalism in the local area.


John Sibley reviews
The Sibley Group
Keller Williams Realty 455-0100

3197 Richland Ave, Metairie, LA 70002

Northshore: 985.326.9755
Southshore: 504.571.9755
Broker: 504.455.0100

From Our Blog

Housing Market Forecasts for the Second Half of the Year

From rising home prices to mortgage rate swings, the housing market has left a lot of people … [Read More]

Why Some Homes Sell Faster Than Others

As you think ahead to your own move, you may have noticed some houses sell within days, while others … [Read More]

Search Links

  • Search Listings
  • Search by Map
  • Login






Keller Williams Realty Professionals

The name of the company is Keller Williams Realty 455-0100.
Each Office is Independently Owned & Operated.

Broker & Associates are licensed by the State of Louisiana.
Copyright © 2019 All Rights Reserved