The Sibley Group at Keller Williams Realty 455-0100

Your Home For New Orleans Real Estate

  • Home
  • Sellers
    • Make a Good First Impression
    • What’s My Home Worth?
    • Determining The Value of Your Home
    • Foreclosure & Short Sales
      • What is a “Short Sale”?
      • Short Sale Process
    • Real Estate Glossary
  • Buyers
    • Find Homes For Sale
    • Get Pre-Approved
    • Making an Offer
    • Mortgage Resource Center
      • FHA Loans
      • RD Financing – Rural Development Loans
      • VA Loans
      • Construction & Renovation Loans
    • Real Estate Glossary
  • Communities
    • Northshore
      • Slidell
      • Mandeville
      • Covington
    • Southshore
      • Uptown
      • Garden District
      • Carrollton / University
      • Broadmoor
      • Lakeview
      • Mid City
      • Warehouse District and CBD
      • French Quarter
      • Marigny and Bywater
      • Metairie
  • Resources
    • Local Area Schools
    • Moving Center
    • Preferred Vendors
    • Hurricane Preparedness
    • Blog
  • Listings
    • View Our Listings
    • Search All Listings
  • About Us
    • The Sibley Group
      • Our Team
      • Reviews & Testimonials
    • Keller Williams Realty
    • Careers
    • Choosing a REALTOR
    • Client Services
  • Contact Us
  • Property SearchSearch Homes By Map
  • Listings By EmailListings Updates Sent To Your Inbox
  • Home ValuationWhat Is Your Home Worth?
  • My AccountLogin To Save Listings And Searches
You are here: Home / Blog / Should You Rent Your House or Sell It?

Should You Rent Your House or Sell It?

February 1, 2023 by John Sibley

Should You Rent Your House or Sell It? Simplifying The Market

If you’re a homeowner ready to make a move, you may be thinking about using your current house as a short-term rental property instead of selling it. A short-term rental (STR) is typically offered as an alternative to a hotel, and they’re an investment that’s gained popularity in recent years. According to a Harris Poll survey, 28% of homeowners have considered using a rental service to temporarily rent out their home for additional income.

Owning a short-term rental can be a tempting idea, but you may find the reality of being responsible for one difficult to take on. Here are some of the challenges you could face if you rent out your house instead of selling it.

A Short-Term Rental Comes with Responsibilities

Successfully owning and renting a house takes work. Think through your ability to make that commitment, especially if you plan to use a platform that advertises your rental listing. Most of them have specific requirements hosts have to meet, and it takes a lot of work. A recent article from Bankrate explains:

“Managing a rental property can be time-consuming and challenging. Are you handy and able to make some repairs yourself? If not, do you have a network of affordable contractors you can reach out to in a pinch? Consider whether you want to take on the added responsibility of being a landlord, which means screening tenants and fielding issues, among other responsibilities, or paying for a third party to take care of things instead.”

Not only is there the upfront time and cost of owning a short-term rental, but there are also risks that could come up for you down the road. Investopedia warns:

“Risks of hosting include renting your place to rude guests, theft or damaged property, complaints from neighbors, and potential regulatory violations depending on your location.”

There’s a lot to consider before taking the leap and converting your house into a short-term rental. If you aren’t ready for the work it takes, it could be wiser to sell instead.

Your House May Not Be Ideal for Your Rental Goals

Not every house ends up being a profitable short-term rental either. One of the biggest factors is where your home is located. The less likely your neighborhood is to be a travel destination, the fewer requests you should expect from potential renters—and that impacts your bottom line. An article from the National Association of Realtors (NAR) advises:

“When it comes to the viability of profitable STRs . . . consider factors like location, amenities, and whether the property is appealing. Most people seek STRs in locations where they vacation, so proximity to attractions is important. Likewise, the property should cater to a variety of travelers.”

It’s smart to do your homework and learn how much rentals in your area go for, how much business they get throughout the year, and how this compares to your goals.

Bottom Line

Converting your home into a short-term rental isn’t a decision you should make without doing your research. To decide if selling your house is a better alternative, let’s connect today.

Receive A Free Guide To Buying or Selling Your Home

The process of buying or selling a home can be overwhelming at times. It’s difficult to know when is the best time to buy, or how to get the most money for your house when selling. You don't need to go through the process alone.

Our free eGuides will answer many of your questions and likely bring up a few things you didn’t even know you should consider when buying or selling a home.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Filed Under: Blog, For Sellers, Selling Myths

Homes By Price Range

Homes Under $200,000

Homes $200,000 – $300,000

Homes $300,000 – $400,000

Homes $400,000 – $500,000

Homes $500,000 – $600,000

Homes $600,000 – $750,000

Homes $750,000 – $1,000,000

Homes Over $1,000,000

Homes by School District

  • Your Contact Information

WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING

John Sibley came highly recommended by a neighbor and he sold our house not only once but twice! A pipe burst upstairs and flooded the house and the first sale was cancelled. We were out of town and John and his staff handled everything from informing us of the problem to working with the adjusters giving them access to the house. When we got back in town just three days later, the damage was already cleaned up and we were ready to begin the repairs!

Default Avatar75
Marilyn, Slidell, LA
 

We were very happy with the service provided. As first time home buyers, we were initially anxious, however, John and the rest of the group helped us understand the home buying process and what to expect. They made sure we were well prepared by the closing and that our interests were top priority.

Default Avatar75
Jimmy, New Orleans, LA
 

John was great to work with. He provided good sound advice relative to marketing our home. He kept me informed through every step of the process from the initial listing to the closing. It was a great experience and I recommend the Sibley Group to anyone interested in purchasing or selling real estate property.

Avatar
Richard, Madisonville, LA
 

John Sibley and Lana Sibley Leonard were very instrumental in marketing my home both personably and professionally. Their drive and incentive made it possible for my home to sell in a quick, timely manner.

Avatar
Christina, Slidell, LA
 

Everyone throughout the process was extremely helpful. Dianna spent a lot of time, including late hours helping us find the right house.

Default Avatar75
Chris, Slidell, LA
 

John & company were always negotiating on my behalf and won the battle such as letting me have an Estate Sale w/o charging me rent for one week and then the new owner moved in. The Sibley Realty Group was always professional in every way.

Default Avatar75
Anonymous, Slidell, LA
 

Sibley's group is the best we've used.

Default Avatar75
Cathy & Will, Slidell, LA
 

John and the Sibley Realty Group had a great command of the market prices and an excellent marketing strategy to get new groups of people to look at our property. By using new technology to market to different buyers and target new groups of potential buyers the Sibley Realty Group met our goal of selling within 3 months. The entire office helped make the transition smooth and Lauren is very helpful making sure everyone is on the same page as you go through the closing process. It is good t(...)

Default Avatar75
Kevin, New Orleans, LA
 

Sibley Group delivered as promised.

Default Avatar75
Stan, New Orleans, LA
 

We are extremely grateful to have found Sibley Realty group. Initially I had called other realtors who were not so responsive since we did not live in the area. Jordan contacted me back right away and made us feel at ease with our first home purchase. We lived 7 hours away from where we were buying and Jordan was very accomendating to our schedule of only being able to make it down on the weekends. The whole office are a bunch of true professionals that we owe more gratitiude to then we can(...)

Default Avatar75
Troy, Slidell, LA
 

From Our Blog

Have You Thought About Why You Might Want To Sell Your House? [INFOGRAPHIC]

… [Read More...]

Why Buying a Home Is a Sound Decision

If you’re thinking about buying a home, you want to know the decision will be a good one. And for … [Read More...]

About Us

The Sibley Group has a team of Realtors to meet all of your real estate needs throughout the New Orleans Metropolitan area. We have agents that specialize on the Northshore and Southshore, including New Orleans, Slidell, Metairie, Covington, Mandeville, Pearl River, and Lacombe.


Trust a real estate team with a long-standing tradition of service, expertise, and professionalism in the local area.


John Sibley reviews
The Sibley Group
Keller Williams Realty 455-0100

3197 Richland Ave, Metairie, LA 70002

Northshore: 985.326.9755
Southshore: 504.571.9755
Broker: 504.455.0100

From Our Blog

Have You Thought About Why You Might Want To Sell Your House? [INFOGRAPHIC]

… [Read More]

Why Buying a Home Is a Sound Decision

If you’re thinking about buying a home, you want to know the decision will be a good one. And for … [Read More]

Search Links

  • Search Listings
  • Search by Map
  • Login






Keller Williams Realty Professionals

The name of the company is Keller Williams Realty 455-0100.
Each Office is Independently Owned & Operated.

Broker & Associates are licensed by the State of Louisiana.
Copyright © 2019 All Rights Reserved